Happy Endings for Over 60 Once-Neglected Cats as Former Owner is Sentenced

May 3, 2018

Happy and Hola

What do five once-neglected cats rescued by the ASPCA have in common today? 

Aside from their rescue by the New York City Police Department (NYPD) and ASPCA from deplorable conditions in a Queens residence (along with more than 60 other animals) in January 2016, these five—and many others—today live the “cat’s meow.” Their previous owner, Elizabeth Grant, was convicted on 108 counts of animal cruelty and sentenced this past Monday to three years’ probation, with conditions.

The ASPCA checked in with four families who fostered (and later adopted) five of the rescued cats for six months to a year while the case was being handled in court. 

“Opening your heart and home to an animal in need—particularly one being rescued from cruelty or neglect—is crucial to not only that animal’s recovery but the ASPCA’s ability to take in even more animals at risk,” said Eileen Hanavan, Senior Manager, Foster & Offsite Programs, ASPCA Adoption Center.

Being rescued from a criminal case of cruelty or neglect can mean weeks, or even months, of legal limbo as the case makes its way through the court system and ownership is ultimately determined. During that time, a foster family often provides a loving home and a safe springboard to eventual adoption for these victims.

For these five cats, those temporary homes proved permanent. Here are their inspiring stories.

Hestia, now Tia


Katie M., a physical therapist who lives on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, fostered Hestia, (now known as Tia), a grey-and-white, six-and-a-half-year-old domestic shorthair, for nearly a year. It was no surprise when she adopted her in April 2017.

“I was with her for so long I felt like I had already adopted her,” admits Katie. “I grew pretty attached to her.”

Tia and Katie

Tia had given birth to four kittens—all of whom have since been adopted—and lived in a previous foster home before she went to live with Katie. She suffered from severe gum disease, which necessitated dental surgery, during which all but three of her teeth were extracted. 

Tia was initially fearful. “When I first got her, she hissed a lot and was apprehensive with people,” explains Katie, who has been an ASPCA volunteer for nearly two years. “She was very territorial but is a lot more comfortable now.”


Tia is Katie’s first pet since moving to Manhattan from her family’s home in New Jersey. Katie reports that Tia loves to play with bottle caps and small balls with bells inside them, and is especially mesmerized by the television series Planet Earth.


“She loves to watch nature shows,” says Katie. “She will sit there as long as it’s on, especially if there are animals on screen.”

Tia is an only cat—and prefers it that way.  Katie says it’s hard to fathom how many animals Tia had to compete with for resources in her previous life in an overcrowded home. 

“I’m sure it was stressful for her to be around other animals,” Katie says. “I’m so glad she’s out of that situation.”


With four white socks and captivating green eyes, Tia is as beautiful as she is affectionate.

“It’s been a great experience having her,” says Katie. “Even with my friends who aren’t cat people—she’s brought them around. One friend adopted two cats after meeting Tia. She’s a great pet.”



Malakai, a six-year-old black and white cat, was in his third foster home with Melissa M. when she decided to adopt him in April 2017.

“I’ve fostered a lot of cats,” says Melissa, who is also an ASPCA volunteer. “Malakai was no different. He was scared of everything, and you could tell he hadn’t had a great life.”

She remembers their first night together. “He whined and whined all night,” she recalls. “I remember thinking, ‘I’m going to be up all night.’ I eventually went to sleep in the living room, where he was, and it got better.”


Despite her lack of sleep that first night, Melissa knew Malakai would come around. 

“You see, as time goes by there is such a change in the animal,” explains Melissa. “He went from no human interaction and then to two foster homes before me, but he now falls asleep in my lap—or anywhere—because he’s so comfortable.” 

Malakai is so laid back, in fact, that he doesn’t mind dressing up for Halloween or other holidays.


“I have a lot of fun with him—he’s extremely tolerant,” says Melissa, whose other two cats—three-year-old Alfie, whom she fostered as a tiny neonate, and Dori, a 10-year-old whom she adopted in her home state of Connecticut—will not stand for silliness, but they get along with Malakai. 

Malakai often sports a lion’s groom and has had several teeth extracted, so his tongue sticks out from time to time. He loves people and children, and is the first of Melissa’s cats to grab a spot on her lap when she is on the couch.


“It’s a great feeling to see such a change in Malakai’s personality and comfort level,” she says.

Andy, now Lil Stevie

Lil Stevie

Lucy L. first saw Andy in July 2016, during an ASPCA introductory foster orientation class that she attended with her then roommate. 

“They created a slideshow of cats who needed to be fostered,” Lucy explains. As picture after picture of adorable felines shone on the screen, each was claimed by other eager foster parents. “You’d see their cute faces and think, ‘I want that one!’” adds Lucy. 

Then came Andy’s picture. Both eyes were scarred from serious eye infections, and he was on the skinny side.

Lil stevie

“We said, ‘Give us whoever you think would be best for us and who needs us most,’” Lucy recalls. “We took Andy home that day.”

Growing up, Lucy’s family had two dogs, but she always dreamed of having a cat, despite being allergic.  

Having recently graduated from college and landing her first job in New York City, Lucy wanted to test the waters by fostering to see if she was ready for the commitment of adoption, and if her allergies had abated. Fortunately, both proved to be true. 

Through the months she fostered him, Lucy helped Andy (now knows as Lil Stevie) learn to trust that he would be fed regularly and that being picked up could be a pleasurable experience.

Lil Stevie, Will, and Lucy

“Even though he has eye issues, that doesn’t stop him from getting around and playing,” Lucy says. “Now he’s much calmer during feeding time, and he lets me hold him and cuddles with me in my sweatshirt—it’s very sweet.”


Once Lil Stevie’s adoption was made official in April 2017, Lucy dreamed of adding another feline to the home she now shares with her boyfriend, Will. 

Today Lil Stevie has a younger sister, 11-month-old Kisa, also adopted from the ASPCA. They took a little while to get used to one another, a process that was made a slightly more challenging due to Stevie’s limited vision. But now, the two felines are fast friends who cuddle and groom each other.

Lil Stevie, Will, and Lucy

Lucy remains in awe of Stevie and the gift that fostering has given her. “I feel like some people have this idea of the perfect animal companion,” she says. “But [despite his physical flaws] it was love at first sight for me and Stevie. It’s been a very good transformation for that little guy.”

Hola and Happy

Happy and Hola

Margalit S. had just enrolled in the ASPCA’s volunteer foster program orientation when she met her husband-to-be, Sam, in August of 2015. By November, they were engaged, and the following May, they wed.

And when Margalit renewed her commitment to the ASPCA, this time Sam accompanied her to the orientation.

“Now that we were married, I decided we both had to go,” recalls Margalit. “As newlyweds we did everything together.”

While her husband wasn’t keen on bringing home two rambunctious five-month-old cats, the couple agreed to foster Hola and Happy—their first-ever fosters. The pair were born after their mother was rescued and had lived in two previous foster homes before joining Margalit and Sam in their Queens apartment.

Happy and Hola

“We didn’t know how long we’d have them, but as the case moved forward, we decided we were ready for a pet,” says Margalit, who had dogs from the time she was 12. By comparison, Sam, the eldest of nine children, didn’t have pets growing up.  

“Two months in, I was crying at the thought of giving them away,” Margalit adds. “I knew I was a goner—a true foster failure.”

On April 21, 2017, the couple officially adopted the cats, whose personalities are totally different.


“They amuse each other and love their togetherness, but Happy is snuggly and likes to be petted, while Hola is curious, mischievous, and likes to explore,” explains Margalit. “They bring joy and companionship and definitely entertainment. Our whole extended family is getting used to having animals. A lot of my friends have kids, and they bring them over to socialize with Hola and Happy.”


As for Sam, “He loves them,” Margalit says. “I knew he would. And I get to say, ‘I told you so.’ That always feels good.”