Shop With Your Heart - Valentine’s Day Shopping List

February 10, 2020
Latest Update: June 8, 2021


This Valentine’s Day, share the love with our animal friends! Whether you’ve got a special someone to impress or are celebrating with your closest friends, make the holiday even sweeter with welfare-certified candies, dairy-free ice cream, plant-based cookie dough and other humane treats straight from our Shop With Your Heart Grocery List. (Psst: Goodies for furry friends are also listed below!)

Look for the labels! These are the 3 certifications recognized by the ASPCA Shop With Your Heart program:

Animal Welfare Approved

Global Animal Partnership (GAP)

Certified Humane

Animal Welfare Approved (AWA) Global Animal Partnership (GAP) Step 2 and Up Certified Humane (CH)

Or look for a plant-based alternative, denoted by this icon ! When a product shows the basic GAP label without a number, look for separate language on the package identifying the product’s step level.

To purchase these products online or find them in-store, visit our main Grocery List.

Candy & Sweets

  • Amy’s Kitchen – Minty Candy, Dreamy Candy, Sunny Candy 
  • Big Picture Farm – goat milk caramels, chocolate truffles Awa logo
  • Black Mesa Ranch – goat milk caramels certified humane
  • Cocomels – Caramels, Bites 
  • Copper Tail Farm – Goat Milk Caramels, Cajeta Goat Milk Caramel Sauce Animal welfare approved
  • Fraga Farmstead Creamery – goat milk caramels Animal welfare approved
  • Hail Merry – cups, bites, tarts 
  • Little Secrets – dark chocolate crispy wafer, dark chocolate pieces, sea salted peanut pieces, sea salted almond pieces, peppermint pieces 
  • Made In Nature – Ancient Fudge Plant based
  • Prairie Fruits Farm & Creamery – Goat Milk Gelato Animal welfare approved
  • Pure Batch – truffles Plant based
  • Shocolat – Chocolate Spread Plant based
  • Surfing Goat Dairy – goat milk truffles certified humane
  • that's It – truffles Plant based

Cakes, Cookies and Bars

  • Atlas Monroe – Legendary Sweet Potato Cake 
  • The Coconut Collaborative – Dessert Pods, Dark Chocolate Lava Cake, Vanilla Rice Pudding, Double Chocolate Mousse, Chocolate Pudding 

  • Daiya – Cheezecake, dessert bars 
  • Elements Truffles – Chocolate 
  • Hunch Snacks – chocolate wafers Plant based
  • JUST – cookie dough 
  • Lenny and Larry's – The Complete Cookie 
  • Nabati Foods – Cheesecakes 
  • Ona Foods – cookies, bars (contain honey) 
  • Maya's Cookies – Multiple flavors 
  • Nature's Charm – Caramel Sauce, Chocolate Sauce, Butter Scotch Sauce, Matcha Sauce 
  • Paleo Prime – cookies, brownies Plant based
  • Paleo Treats – Bandito, Cacao Now!, Mustang Bar (contains honey) 
  • Partake Foods – cookies plant-based
  • Plant Reality – Cheesecakes Plant based
  • Plantmade – Coconut Cream Pie, Strawberry Cream Pie plant-based
  • Pure Batch – cookies, brownies Plant based
  • Red Plate Foods – Cookies, Cupcakes, Muffins Plant based
  • Rickaroons Energy Bars 
  • Southern Roots Vegan Bakery – Donuts, Brownies, Cookies Plant based
  • That's Hella Nutz – Nice Cream, Creme Brulee Plant based
  • Uncle Eddie's Vegan Cookies – Multiple Flavors Plant based
  • Uplift Food – cookies Plant based
  • Vegin' Out – cookies Plant based
  • Yummy Doh – edible cookie dough Plant based

Frozen Desserts 

  • Arctic Zero – Faba Bean Frozen Dessert 
  • Ben & Jerry’s – dairy-free line 
  • Blue Skies – ice cream Plant based
  • Brave Robot – ice cream Plant based

  • Breyers – non-dairy frozen desserts 
  • Craig's – Multiple Flavors 
  • DiNoci Dairy Free – Ice Cream 
  • Eat MUD – dairy-free ice cream sweetened with dates 
  • Enlightened – dairy-free pints and bars Plant-based
  • Frankie & Jo's Vegan Ice Cream 
  • Häagen-Dazs – dairy-free line 
  • New Barn – AlmondCrème 
  • Oatly – frozen dessert Plant based
  • O'My Dairy Free Gelato – various flavors Plant based
  • Revolution Gelato – organic gelato 
  • Ripple – frozen desserts, multiple flavors 
  • Smitten Ice Cream – ice cream Plant based

  • Snow Monkey – Dairy Free Frozen Dessert Plant based

  • So Delicious – mousse, frozen desserts, dessert bars, fudge bars, sandwiches, frozen dessert topping 
  • Sweet Nothings – frozen snacks, various flavors Plant based
  • Van Leeuwen – vegan ice cream 
  • Wink Frozen Desserts – ice cream 

Pet Treats

  • Earth Animal – Dr. Bob Goldstein's Wisdom Dog Food - Chicken Recipe GAP Step 2
  • Fido Biotics – probiotics for dogs, multiple flavors 
  • Fido Biotics – probiotics for cats, multiple flavors 
  • FreshPet - Nature's Fresh Line – Chicken GAP Step 2
  • Halo Pet – Holistic Garden of Vegan adult dog food, Sensitive Stomach daily prebiotic & digestive support 
  • Happy N’ Healthy Dog Treats – organic beef liver GAP step 4
  • Aryshire Farms - MeatMe petfood - Cat Food and Treats – chicken, beef, turkey certified humane
  • Aryshire Farms - MeatMe petfood - Dog Food and Treats – chicken, beef, turkey certified humane
  • Nuggets Healthy Eats – Chicken Bone Broth Jerky, Chicken Bone Brew Products *All Chicken Products Will Have The GAP2 Seal By Spring 2021. GAP Step 2

  • Open Farm Dog Treats – beef GAP step 4; turkey & chicken certified humane
  • Raw Dog – Raw Goat Milk Probiotic for Cats and Dogs certified humane
  • Raw Farm – Grass Fed Raw Kefir, Grass Fed Raw Milk GAP step 4
  • Straight Arrow Bison – Freeze-Dried Dog Treats Awa logo
  • Tender & True Dog Treat – organic chicken jerky treat GAP step 3 ; lamb jerky treat GAP Step 4
  • V-Dog – Dog food, treats, and chews Plant based
  • White Oak Pastures – pet chews GAP Step 5+
  • Wild Earth – dog treats Plant based

If you’re baking for your sweetie, please visit for a full list of our welfare-certified egg and dairy ingredients as well as plant-based alternatives.

If you are having trouble finding welfare-certified or plant-based alternatives, let your local grocery store know you'd like more humane products or order ahead online!

Please contact us at [email protected] if we have missed a company or product that should be on this list.