Shop With Your Heart - Thanksgiving Shopping List

October 2, 2019
Latest Update: September 1, 2020


One thing we can all be grateful for this year is progress for farm animals. As consumers demand more humane alternatives to factory farming, companies and supermarkets are responding by stocking their shelves with plant-based and welfare-certified options.

We’ve crafted a holiday shopping list of the most festive products from our Shop With Your Heart Brand List that have either earned a meaningful animal welfare certification recognized by the ASPCA or are a plant-based alternative. Many of them are available to order online, right to your door! Whether you're looking to spruce up your recipe classics or try something new, there’s something here to delight everyone at the table. Make kindness a part of your family tradition. Happy Thanksgiving!

Look for the labels! These are the 3 certifications recognized by the ASPCA Shop With Your Heart program:

Animal Welfare Approved

Global Animal Partnership (GAP)

Certified Humane

Animal Welfare Approved (AWA) Global Animal Partnership (GAP) Step 2 and Up Certified Humane (CH)

Or look for a plant-based alternative, denoted by this icon ! When a product shows the basic GAP label without a number, look for separate language on the package identifying the product’s step level.

To purchase these products online or find them in-store, visit our main Brand List.


  • Amy’s Kitchen – veggie loafs 
  • Atlas Monroe – organic vegan deep fried & stuffed turkey 
  • D'Artagnan – Green Circle Free Range turkey certified humane
  • Field Roast - loafs, roasts 
  • Firefly Farms certified humane
  • Gardein - loafs, roasts 
  • Koch’s Turkey certified humane
  • Mary’s Free Range Turkey GAP step 3  GAP step 5+
  • Murray’s – ground turkey certified humane
  • Myrtle Greens – Vegan Whole Turkey 
  • Tofurky - roasts
  • White Oak Pastures certified humane GAP step 5+

Broths, Gravies and Soups

  • Beyond Broth 
  • Llano Seco – pork bone broth GAP step 2
  • Manolo's Best – Original Farmstand Chili, Roasted Sweet Potato Chili *only sold in Whole Foods Plant based
  • Tofurky - gravy 
  • White Oak Pastures - beef broth, poultry broth certified humane GAP step 5+

Have you ever tried substituting mushroom gravy or vegetable broth in your holiday classics? They add a rich flavor and cater to everyone at your table!

Sausage (for stuffing)

  • Amy’s Kitchen - sausages 
  • Ayrshire Farm certified humane
  • Boca - crumbles 
  • Fra' Mani certified humane
  • Home Place Pastures – multiple pork products certified humane
  • Joyce Farms – Heritage pork AWA
  • Llano Seco GAP step 2
  • Morningstar Farms - links, patties 
  • Newman Farms certified humane
  • Niman Ranch certified humane
  • North Country Smokehouse certified humane
  • Tofurky - sausages 
  • White Oak Pastures GAP step 5+
  • Yves - patties, crumbles, ground round, stuffers 

Milk & Alternatives

  • Almond Breeze – almond milks Plant-based
  • Califia Farms – almond milk, oat milk, coconut milk, cashew milk, creamers Plant-based
  • Eden Soy – soy milk Plant-based
  • Good Karma – flax milk Plant-based
  • Milkadamia – macadamia milk Plant-based
  • New Barn – almond milk, coconut milk, creamers Plant-based
  • O Organics – almond milk Plant-based
  • Oatly! – Barista Edition, regular, low-fat, chocolate Plant-based
  • Organic Pastures – milk, cream Certified Humane
  • Pacific Foods – almond milk, hemp milk, soy milk, hazelnut milk, rice milk, oat milk, coconut milk, cashew milk Plant-based
  • Planet Oat Oatmilk – oat milk Plant-based
  • Quaker Oat Beverage – oat milk Plant-based
  • Rice Dream – rice milk Plant-based
  • Ripple – pea milk Plant-based
  • Silk – soy milk, almond milk, oat milk, coconut milk, cashew milk Plant-based
  • So Delicious – almond milk, coconut milk, cashew milk, creamers Plant-based
  • Summer Hill Goat Dairy – all products certified Certified Humane
  • Tempt – hemp milk Plant-based
  • Working Cows Dairy – milk, whipping cream Animal Welfare Approved

Butter & Spreads

  • Aldi: Earth Grown – vegan cream cheese *only available in select stores Plant-based
  • Daiya – cream Cheeze Plant-based
  • Earth Balance – spread, sticks Plant-based
  • Follow Your Heart – cream cheese 
  • Go Veggie – cream cheese 
  • Green Valley Organics – all products certified Certified Humane
  • Kite Hill – cream cheese 
  • Miyoko's Creamery – butter, cream cheese Plant-based
  • New Barn – organic buttery spread Plant-based
  • Organic Pastures – raw butter Certified Humane
  • Truly Grass-Fed – butter Animal Welfare Approved


  • Atlas Monroe – Legendary Sweet Potato Cake 
  • Ben & Jerry’s – dairy-free line 
  • Breyers – non-dairy frozen desserts 
  • Daiya – cheezecake, dessert bars 
  • Eat MUD – dairy-free ice cream sweetened with dates 
  • Enlightened – dairy-free pints and bars Plant-based
  • Frankie & Jo’s Vegan Ice Cream 
  • Häagen-Dazs – dairy-free line 
  • O'My Dairy Free Gelato – various flavors 
  • Revolution Gelato – organic gelato 
  • So Delicious – mousse, frozen desserts, dessert bars, fudge bars, sandwiches, frozen dessert topping 
  • This Pie Is Nuts – various pies 
  • Van Leeuwen – vegan ice cream 
  • Wink Frozen Desserts – ice cream, cookies 

Baby Food

  • Serenity Kids – pasture-raised turkey with sweet potato, pumpkin and beet GAP Step 4
  • Serenity Kids – organic butternut squash and spinach Plant based
  • Serenity Kids – organic roots Plant based
  • Serenity Kids – organic squashes Plant based
  • Serenity Kids – organic sweet potato and spinach Plant based

For a full list of certified meat, egg and dairy brands as well as plant-based alternatives that you can find in stores and online, please visit

If you are having trouble finding welfare-certified or plant-based alternatives, let your local grocery store know you want them to stock more humane products!

Please contact us at [email protected] if we have missed a company or product that should be on this list.