Bake With Your Heart - Holiday Baking Ingredient List

November 1, 2019
Latest Update: September 30, 2021

 Dog looking at pie

Get ready, humane holiday bakers! ‘Tis the season to impress with your tastiest—and most animal-friendly—baked goods. Whether you’re whipping up your holiday classic for a dessert table centerpiece or trying out a new recipe for a cookie swap, check out our shopping list of plant-based and animal welfare-certified baking ingredients pulled straight from our Shop With Your Heart Grocery List. Happy baking!

Did you make an impressive batch? Please share a photo of your baked goods and tag @ASPCA with the hashtag #ShopWithYourHeart!

Look for the labels! These are the 3 certifications recognized by the ASPCA Shop With Your Heart program:

Animal Welfare Approved

Global Animal Partnership (GAP)

Certified Humane

Animal Welfare Approved (AWA) Global Animal Partnership (GAP) Step 2 and Up Certified Humane (CH)

Or look for a plant-based alternative, denoted by this icon ! When a product shows the basic GAP label without a number, look for separate language on the package identifying the product’s step level.

To purchase these products online or find them in-store, visit our main Grocery List.


  • Albertsons – O Organics Cage-Free eggs, Open Nature cage-free eggs certified humane
  • Alderfer’s Eggs certified humane
  • Aldi – Simply Nature cage-free organic eggs *only available in select stores certified humane
  • Alexandre Family Farm – Pasture Raised Eggs; All Products Certified certified humane
  • Blue Sky Family Farms certified humane
  • Bob's Red Mill Egg Replacer – powder 
  • Born Free Eggs certified humane
  • Carol’s Eggs certified humane
  • Central Market – organic pasture-raised eggs certified humane
  • Contented Hen certified humane
  • Consider Pasture – pasture-raised eggs certified humane
  • Costco – Kirkland Signature organic eggs certified humane
  • The Country Hen – organic brown eggs certified humane
  • Davidson’s Safest Choice Cage-Free Eggs certified humane
  • Eco Meal Cage-Free Eggs certified humane
  • Eggology – all cage free products certified certified humane
  • Ener-G Egg Replacer – egg 
  • The Farmer’s Hen – cage-free brown eggs, organic cage-free brown eggs, hard cooked & peeled cage-free eggs certified humane
  • Farmer’s Hen House certified humane
  • Follow Your Heart – VeganEgg 
  • Giving Nature certified humane
  • Green Meadow Organics certified humane
  • Happy Belly Cage-Free Eggs certified humane
  • Harris Teeter Free Range Brown Eggs Certified humane
  • Ingles Market – Laura Lynn eggs certified humane
  • Judy’s Family Farm certified humane
  • Lathem Farms certified humane
  • Meijer – True Goodness Free Range Eggs certified humane
  • Natural Grocers – pasture-raised eggs certified humane
  • Nature Fed Cage-Free Eggs certified humane
  • Nature’s Yoke – organic, pasture-raised and free-range eggs certified humane
  • Neat – egg substitute Plant based
  • Nellie’s Free Range Eggs certified humane
  • Nest Fresh certified humane
  • New Seasons Market – cage-free eggs, free range organic brown eggs certified humane
  • Pete and Gerry’s certified humane
  • Phil’s Fresh Eggs certified humane
  • Raley’s: Cage-Free Brown Eggs certified humane
  • Safeway – O Organic Cage-Free eggs, Open Nature cage-free eggs certified humane
  • Sam's Club – Member's Mark Cage Free Eggs certified humane
  • Sauders – cage-free brown, free range, pasture-raised eggs certified humane
  • Shaws – O Organics Cage-Free eggs, Open Nature cage-free eggs certified humane
  • South Mountain Creamery Cage-Free Brown Eggs certified humane
  • Stiebrs Farms – Sunrise Fresh, Go-Organic, Natural Choice eggs certified humane
  • Utopihen – Pasture Raised Eggs certified humane
  • Vital Farms certified humane
  • Vons – O Organics Cage-Free eggs, Open Nature cage-free eggs certified humane
  • White Oak Pastures certified humane
  • Wilcox Farms certified humane
Butter & Spreads
  • Ahara Ghee – Gourmet Clarified Butter 
  • Aldi: Earth Grown – vegan cream cheese *only available in select stores 
  • Daiya – Cream Cheeze 
  • Earth Balance – spread, sticks 
  • Follow Your Heart – cream cheese 
  • Go Veggie – cream cheese 
  • Green Valley Organics certified humane
  • Joia Food Farm – All products certified Animal Welfare Approved
  • Kite Hill – Butter, cream cheese 
  • Melt Organic – butter 
  • Miyoko’s Creamery – butter, cream cheese, cheese spread 
  • Raw Farm – raw butter certified humane
  • Truly Grass-Fed – butter Animal Welfare Approved
  • Zeal Creamery Animal Welfare Approved
  • Alexandre Family Farm – Grass Fed Milk; All Products Certified certified humane
  • Almond Breeze – almond milks 
  • Califia Farms – almond milk, oat milk, coconut milk, cashew milk, creamers 
  • Chef's Choice – Coconut Milk, Coconut Cream 
  • The Coconut Company – Coconut Milk Powder 
  • Dream – rice milk 
  • Eden Soy – soy milk 
  • Good Karma – flax milk 
  • Hart Dairy –  Grass Fed Milk, Grass Fed Chocolate Milk certified humane
  • Milkadamia – macadamia milk 
  • Nature's Charm – Coconut Milk, Coconut Whipping Cream 
  • New Barn – Almond Milk 
  • O Organics – almond milk 
  • Oatly! – Barista Edition, regular, low-fat, chocolate 
  • Oatsome – Oat milk 
  • Organic Pastures – milk, cream certified humane
  • Pacific Foods – almond milk, hemp milk, soy milk, hazelnut milk, rice milk, oat milk, coconut milk, cashew milk 
  • Planet Oat Oatmilk – oat milk 
  • Pure Eire Dairy Awa logo
  • Quaker Oat Beverage – oat milk 
  • Real Coco – Coconut Milk, Coconut Creamer 
  • Ripple – pea milk 
  • Silk – soy milk, almond milk, oat milk, coconut milk, cashew milk 
  • So Delicious – creamers, almond milk, coconut milk, cashew milk 
  • Summer Hill Goat Dairy certified humane
  • Take Two – Barley Milk 
  • Tempt – hemp milk 
  • Working Cows Dairy – milk, whipping cream Awa logo
  • Zeal Creamery Animal Welfare Approved
For a full list of certified meat, egg and dairy brands as well as plant-based alternatives that you can find in stores and online, please visit

If you are having trouble finding welfare-certified or plant-based alternatives, let your local grocery store know you want them to stock more humane products!

Please contact us at [email protected] if we have missed a company or product that should be on this list.