November 28, 2018

Bake With Your Heart - Holiday Baking Ingredient List

Get ready, humane holiday bakers! ‘Tis the season to impress with your tastiest—and most animal-friendly—baked goods. Whether you’re whipping up your holiday classic for a dessert table centerpiece or trying out a new recipe for a cookie swap, check out our shopping list of plant-based and animal welfare-certified baking ingredients pulled straight from our Shop With Your Heart brand list. Happy baking!

Did you make an impressive batch? Please share a photo of your baked goods and tag @ASPCA with the hashtag #BakeWithYourHeart!

Look for the labels! These are the 3 certifications recognized by the ASPCA Shop With Your Heart program:

Animal Welfare Approved

 
Global Animal Partnership (GAP)
 

Certified Humane

Animal Welfare Approved (AWA) Global Animal Partnership (GAP) Step 2 and Up Certified Humane (CH)

(or a plant-based alternative, denoted by this icon !) When a product shows the basic GAP label without a number, look for separate language on the package identifying the product’s step level. Many are available at supermarkets in store across the country, while others are available for purchase online online.

Eggs

  • Alderfer’s Eggs certified humane in store online
  • Aldi: Simply Nature Cage-Free Organic Eggs certified humane in store
  • Ayrshire Farm certified humane online
  • Barnstar – Cage-Free, Organic Brown Eggs certified humane in store
  • Blue Sky Family Farms certified humane in store
  • Born Free Eggs certified humane in store
  • Carol’s Eggs certified humane in store online
  • Central Market: Organic Pasture Raised Eggs certified humane in store
  • Contented Hen certified humane in store
  • Costco: Kirkland Organic Eggs certified humane in store
  • Davidson’s Safest Choice Cage-Free Eggs certified humane in store
  • Eco Meal Cage-Free Eggs certified humane in store
  • Eggology – Pure Egg Whites, Cage-Free certified humane in store online
  • Farmer’s Hen House certified humane in store
  • Giving Nature certified humane in store
  • Great Day certified humane in store
  • Green Meadow Organics certified humane in store
  • Happy Belly Cage-Free Eggs certified humane in store online
  • Judy’s Family Farm certified humane in store
  • JUST   in store online
  • Lathem Farms certified humane in store
  • Natural Grocers: Pasture-Raised Eggs certified humane in store
  • Nature Fed Cage-Free Eggs certified humane in store
  • Nature’s Yoke Cage-Free Eggs certified humane in store
  • Nellie’s Free Range Eggs certified humane in store online
  • Nest Fresh certified humane in store
  • New Seasons Market: Cage-Free Eggs, Free Range Organic Brown Eggs certified humane in store
  • Pete and Gerry’s certified humane in store online
  • Phil’s Fresh Eggs certified humane in store
  • Raley’s: Cage-Free Brown Eggs certified humane in store online
  • Safeway: O – Organic Eggs & Open Nature Cage-Free Eggs certified humane in store
  • Sauders – Cage-Free Brown, Free Range, Pasture Raised Eggs certified humane in store
  • South Mountain Creamery Cage-Free Brown Eggs certified humane online
  • Stiebrs Farms – Sunrise Fresh, Go-Organic & Natural Choice Eggs  certified humane in store online
  • The Country Hen – Organic Brown Eggs certified humane in store
  • The Farmer’s Hen – Cage-Free Brown Eggs, Organic Cage-Free Brown Eggs, Hard Cooked & Peeled Cage-Free Eggs certified humane in store
  • Vital Farms certified humane in store online
  • White Oak Pastures certified humane in store
  • Wilcox Farms certified humane in store online
Butter & Spreads
  • Daiya Cream Cheeze  in store online
  • Earth Balance – Spread, Sticks  in store online
  • Green Valley Organics certified humane in store online
  • Miyoko’s Creamery – Butter, Cream Cheese, Cheese Spread  in store online
  • Organic Pastures – Raw Butter certified humane online    
Milk
  • Almond Breeze  in store online
  • Organic Pastures – Cream certified humane in store online
  • New Barn – Almond Milk  in store
  • Pure Eire Dairy  Awa logo in store online
  • Silk   in store online
  • So Delicious – Creamers, Almond Milk, Coconut Milk, Cashew Milk   in store online
  • Summer Hill Goat Dairy certified humane in store
  • Working Cows Dairy – Milk, Whipping Cream Awa logo in store
For a full list of certified meat, egg and dairy brands as well as plant-based alternatives that you can find in stores and online, please visit aspca.org/foodbrands.
 
If you are having trouble finding welfare-certified or plant-based alternatives, let your local grocery store know you want them to stock more humane products!